How to add two images and remove the added image
Show older comments
Hi
is it possible to add two image and did after some operation separate added image from it ?
Answers (4)
Image Analyst
on 27 Jan 2013
0 votes
Yes.
10 Comments
goldensona
on 27 Jan 2013
Image Analyst
on 27 Jan 2013
Edited: Image Analyst
on 27 Jan 2013
I know it seems really obvious and trivial, but since you aren't giving any guidance at all, this is all I can suggest:
sumImage = image1+image2;
sumImage = sumImage / 2; % Some arbitrary operation.
% Undue the operation, then subtract image2 to recover image1.
image1Recovered = sumImage * 2 - image2;
Walter Roberson
on 28 Jan 2013
Note that if all you have at the time you want to separate the images is the added image, then separation is not generally possible. (It would be possible in some circumstances where additional information is known.)
goldensona
on 28 Jan 2013
Image Analyst
on 28 Jan 2013
If you don't have at least one of original images, you can't do it. For example, if I gave you the number 100 (let's pretend that is the gray level of an image pixel), can you tell me what two numbers I added together to give that 100? No, you can't. But if I tell you that one of the numbers was 42, then you can figure out the other number was 58.
Walter Roberson
on 28 Jan 2013
Would this have to do with stegnograpy?
goldensona
on 31 Jan 2013
Image Analyst
on 31 Jan 2013
It is a complicated and active field of research. You can find more in section 23.3 here: http://iris.usc.edu/Vision-Notes/bibliography/contentschar.html#OCR,%20Document%20Analysis%20and%20Character%20Recognition%20Systems
goldensona
on 1 Feb 2013
Image Analyst
on 1 Feb 2013
Then either your method of attack was very stealthy and effective, or your method of detecting attacks was unable to beat this method of attack. Do you have any further questions on the original question in this post? If not, go ahead and finish it by marking an accepted answer.
Jan
on 28 Jan 2013
What does "adding" mean here? Do you want to add the pixel values, if so, does this mean averaging or a sum with ignoring the saturation? Or does adding mean a horizontal or vertically concatenation?
Then the meaning of "some operations" is important also: If you perform any destructive operations, you loose information and therefore a perfect reconstruction of the original data is impossible.
Therefore, in opposite to Image Analyst, I would answer:
No, not in general.
1 Comment
goldensona
on 28 Jan 2013
ram
on 1 Mar 2013
0 votes
it is similar kind of tampering. am i right?
ram
on 1 Mar 2013
0 votes
if i cut the portion of one image and paste it in to another image and save as jpg. now i want to separate portion fromthe resultant image. is that possible?
2 Comments
Walter Roberson
on 1 Mar 2013
Similar to what?
Image Analyst
on 1 Mar 2013
It might be, depending on exactly what you did. A simple copy and paste would be detectable with normxcorr2() as long as you know what the pasted portion was - look for my demo on that in the Answers forum. But if you took just one or two pixels from an image and pasted it onto another one, then how do you know if it was pasted, or if the original image had those same pixels prior to pasting?
Categories
Find more on Image Segmentation and Analysis in Help Center and File Exchange
Products
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!