Max in bin using histc

1 view (last 30 days)
K E
K E on 22 Jun 2012
I performed several tests to measure how y depends on x. I repeated the value of x in some of the tests. If x was repeated, the higher values of y are more reliable. Given a vector of x and y, I would like to find (a) the max value of y obtained for each value of x, i.e. selecting the max of the repeated tests plus any y value for which the value of x wasn't retested, and (b) all values of y from the repeated tests that were not the max value. I believe this can be done with a clever application of histc. Here is an example,
x = [ 219 292 292 365 365 365 402 438 438 511 ] ; % Independent variable with some repeats
y = [ 69.9 76.4 72.6 61.6 48.9 77.7 77.6 76 78.9 73.3 ] ; % Dependent variable
iMax = ?? ; % Index to max value of y obtained for each value of x; also include values of y for which x value wasn't retested
plot(x(iMax), y(iMax), 'b') ; hold on ;
iNotMax = ?? % For repeated tests, find index to all non-max values of y
plot(x(iNotMax), y(iNotMax), 'b*') ;
  1 Comment
K E
K E on 22 Jun 2012
I think I can find (a) as follows, then overplot all values to see (b) visually, but perhaps there is a better approach?
%%
[ nInBin, indexToBin ] = histc(x, unique(x)) ;
iGoodBin = indexToBin > 0 ;
maxValue = accumarray(col_vect(indexToBin(iGoodBin)), ...
col_vect(y(iGoodBin)), [], @max, NaN) ;

Sign in to comment.

Accepted Answer

Andrei Bobrov
Andrei Bobrov on 22 Jun 2012
second variant
[a b b] = unique(x);
out = [a',accumarray(b',y',[],@max)];
  1 Comment
K E
K E on 26 Jun 2012
I will accept this one because it is shorter but both solutions work and were useful for learning so thanks to both authors.

Sign in to comment.

More Answers (1)

the cyclist
the cyclist on 22 Jun 2012
Here's one way:
x = [ 219 292 292 365 365 365 402 438 438 511 ];
y = [ 69.9 76.4 72.6 61.6 48.9 77.7 77.6 76 78.9 73.3 ];
z = sortrows([x; y]');
[~,indexToLastUniqueX] = unique(x,'last');
zUnique = z(indexToLastUniqueX,:)
  1 Comment
K E
K E on 26 Jun 2012
Thanks, this solution works and I appreciate it. I was stumped on how to accept 2 answers, seems I can't, so I accepted the shorter one.

Sign in to comment.

Tags

Products

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!