discrete deriviative has wrong sign
    6 views (last 30 days)
  
       Show older comments
    
I have the following MWE that calculates the derivative of a function along the y-direction:
x=1:50;
y=x;
phi = sin((x-10)/10);
dyPhi = (4.0*(circshift(phi(:,:), [+0, +1]) - circshift(phi(:,:), [+0, -1])) + ...
         1.0*(circshift(phi(:,:), [+1, +1]) - circshift(phi(:,:), [-1, -1])) + ...
         1.0*(circshift(phi(:,:), [-1, +1]) - circshift(phi(:,:), [+1, -1])))/12.0;
figure(1)
imagesc(phi)
colorbar
figure(2)
imagesc(dyPhi)
colorbar
However, please take a look at the two plots: On the plot for dyPhi, it seems that the derivative has a wrong sign.
Why is that? If I swap the sign, then I get what I would expect.
0 Comments
Answers (1)
  Adam
      
      
 on 8 Apr 2015
        At a guess I would say it is because circshift shifts in the opposite direction to what you would expect. Certainly that catches me quite often when I have to shift by -1 when I intuitively thought it should be +1
0 Comments
See Also
Categories
				Find more on Calculus in Help Center and File Exchange
			
	Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!
