I am trying to input my found critical point into the second derivative, but when I double it to get an actual value, I get an array of zeros.

3 views (last 30 days)
Q = @(v) sym(v);
Pi = Q(pi);
E = Q(9.9)*10^6;
p = Q(.098);
F = Q(1500);
L = Q(20);
g = Q(32.2)*12;
I = (F*L^2)/(E*Pi^2);
syms R1 t
x = I == (Pi/4)*(((R1+t)^4)-(R1^4));
R = solve(x, R1, 'MaxDegree', 4);
W0 = 2.*Pi.*p.*L.*g.*t.*R;
dW = diff(W0,t)==0;
cp = arrayfun(@(F) vpasolve(F,t), dW(1), 'uniform', 0);
cp{1};
var = double(vpa(vpa(cp{1})));
ddW = diff(dW,t);
ddW_t = subs(ddW, t, var); % Substitute t with the value
number = double(ddW_t);

Accepted Answer

Dyuman Joshi
Dyuman Joshi on 29 Feb 2024
"... but when I double it to get an actual value, I get an array of zeros."
That is because dW is defined as an equation, not an expression.
You can change the definition to an expression and get the results accordingly -
Q = @(v) sym(v);
Pi = Q(pi);
E = Q(9.9)*10^6;
p = Q(.098);
F = Q(1500);
L = Q(20);
g = Q(32.2)*12;
I = (F*L^2)/(E*Pi^2);
syms R1 t
x = I == (Pi/4)*(((R1+t)^4)-(R1^4));
R = solve(x, R1, 'MaxDegree', 4);
W0 = 2.*Pi.*p.*L.*g.*t.*R;
%define dW as an expression
dW = diff(W0,t);
cp = arrayfun(@(F) vpasolve(F,t), dW(1), 'uniform', 0)
cp = 1x1 cell array
{[0.13882567791546955545640596714379]}
var = cp{1}
var = 
0.13882567791546955545640596714379
ddW = diff(dW,t)
ddW = 
ddW_t = subs(ddW, t, var) % Substitute t with the value
ddW_t = 
number = double(ddW_t)
number =
1.0e+03 * -8.3670 + 0.0000i -2.9543 + 0.0541i -2.9543 - 0.0541i
  3 Comments
Oliver Ries
Oliver Ries on 5 Mar 2024
Yes, sorry I forgot to respond to this one. It ended up working although I went a completely different direction and instead of doing the second derivative test, I just returned the lowest weight and the corresponding values, because although this ended up working it still only returned one value every time rather than the 3x1 matrix you are showing.

Sign in to comment.

More Answers (0)

Categories

Find more on Symbolic Math Toolbox in Help Center and File Exchange

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!